Inkipedia:Logo Contest 2022/Round 1

Round 1 is the feedback round. Everyone is encouraged to leave comments with helpful feedback under each proposal. You don't have to say whether you support or oppose a submission, as the most important thing is to provide specific feedback that the artist can use to craft the ultimate logo!

This period will last 4 weeks, during which you may continue submitting new works to receive feedback.

• Every artist who makes a submission will pass the round.
• Please submit as many logo proposals as you want.
• Add your new proposal at the bottom of this page and number it appropriately.
• For revised versions of a previous proposal, you may add them as a new variant under the same proposal (another row in the table).
  • If you feel that the new version is very different, you can submit it as a new proposal with its own section.
• You can copy and paste the following text to display your images in a table. Just make sure the file names point to your images (use the "show preview" button!).

{| class="wikitable"
! Name
! colspan=2 | Icon
! colspan=2 | Wordmark
! colspan=2 | Logo
! Notes
|- style="text-align:center;"
! 1
| [[File:Inkipedia Logo Contest 2022 - YourUsername - Icon Proposal 1.png|50x50px]]
| [[File:Inkipedia Logo Contest 2022 - YourUsername - Icon Proposal 1.png|100x100px]]
| [[File:Inkipedia Logo Contest 2022 - YourUsername - Wordmark Proposal 1.png|x18px]]
| [[File:Inkipedia Logo Contest 2022 - YourUsername - Wordmark Proposal 1.png|x36px]]
| [[File:Inkipedia Logo Contest 2022 - YourUsername - Logo Proposal 1.png|135x135px]]
| [[File:Inkipedia Logo Contest 2022 - YourUsername - Logo Proposal 1.png|270x270px]]
| Optionally, any notes you want to write here.
|}

Proposal example

Write anything you want to say about your submission (use 4 tildes (~~~~) to add your signature)

Name	Icon		Wordmark		Logo		Notes
1	Small icon	Large icon	Small wordmark	Large wordmark	Small logo	Large logo	Optionally, any notes you want to write here.
Another variant/version if there is one	Small icon	Large icon	Small wordmark	Large wordmark	Small logo	Large logo	Optionally, any notes you want to write about this variant.

Comments

• Comments are closed because this is just an example.

Proposal 1

Mr. Hinoshin (talk) 11:09, 8 May 2022 (UTC)

Name	Icon		Wordmark		Logo		Notes
1							Tried to match Splatoon 3's chaotic style. Everything, execpt the grey squid icon, was manually recreated. Flexable with colors, besides most of the graffiti. Still working on placement of graffiti and fixing minor graphical errors. Need to correct size of logo and icon to be exact 1 by 1.

Comments

• Support. A fantastic first submission to the contest! Heddy (talk) 11:32, 8 May 2022 (UTC)
• Support. This slaps. I love what you’ve done for the chaos theme, and although it’s a little bit busy in terms of colours when small, it’s also bold and original! I’m wondering if the main yellow circle and squid could be made a bit bigger to stand out more? Either way, loving it, great stuff. GloverMist (talk) 12:35, 8 May 2022 (UTC)
• Support. It's beautiful. On smaller sizes it's a bit condensed but overall I love the chaos and the athetetics. Shahar (talk) 12:54, 8 May 2022 (UTC)
• Support. This is amazing! I love how it matches the theme of Splatoon 3, while staying original and totally awesome. I can imagine it on the main page and I think it would look phenomenal! WoomyGirl85 (talk) 13:09, 8 May 2022 (UTC)
• Support. This is AMAZING. It really fits with Splatoon 3, and it would look really nice on the main page! SplatonGamer (talk) 13:34, 8 May 2022 (UTC)
• Support. Hey, I love this!!! One thing, I think the wordmark would look better with Splatoon's other font ninckmane (talk) 14:08, 8 May 2022 (UTC)Vinny
• I'm a bit worried that this wordmark looks like the actual Splatoon font. I would prefer to see something original and uniquely yours for the wordmark, rather than taken directly from a game. With small tweaks to the wordmark it could still have a Splatoon feel while being uniquely yours, just like the graffiti. I think the icon could be tweaked to look better at small size; it doesn't have to be the same as the full logo, you can do whatever you need to do to tweak the icon version of the art to be optimal for that size. Heddy (talk) 14:52, 8 May 2022 (UTC)
• Support. I love the chaotic energy this gives off and the overall style suits Splatoon 3 amazingly well! ShadowLugia250 (talk) 16:31, 8 May 2022 (UTC)
• Support. User:Eminence/Sig3 10:25, 9 May 2022 (UTC)

Proposal 2

DedSplat1369 (talk) 13:26, 8 May 2022‎ (UTC)

Name	Icon		Wordmark		Logo		Notes
1	File:Inkipedia Logo Contest 2022 - DedSplat1369 - Icon Proposal 1.png	File:Inkipedia Logo Contest 2022 - DedSplat1369 - Icon Proposal 1.png			File:Inkipedia Logo Contest 2022 - DedSplat1369 - Logo Proposal 1.png	File:Inkipedia Logo Contest 2022 - DedSplat1369 - Logo Proposal 1.png	By the way, I didn't draw any of this. I put it together on a graphic designing app called Canva. I'm just an amateur graphic designer that thinks he's got skills. I don't want the prize, do whatever you want with it. There's really no theme here, but I did try to go with the yellow and blue theme of Splatoon 3. Also, I doubled the size for the files by accident instead of halved. Oops lol
2	File:Inkipedia Logo Contest 2022 - DedSplat1369 - Icon Proposal 1.png	File:Inkipedia Logo Contest 2022 - DedSplat1369 - Icon Proposal 1.png			File:Inkipedia Logo Contest 2022 - DedSplat1369 - Logo Proposal 3.png	File:Inkipedia Logo Contest 2022 - DedSplat1369 - Logo Proposal 3.png	New and improved version of my logo. I still can't draw, so I did't change any elements. I did darken the circle in the back for more contrast and put a background on the text for it to stand out more. By the way, please remember that I'm still an amateur in graphic designing and can't draw that well either.

Comments

• Neutral. The icon looks decent despite your lack of confidence in your work. I noticed that many parts are green, so there isn't much contrast. Maybe you could tweak the colors? The thing that stands out the most is the eyes, strangely. You said that you didn't draw it, what does that mean? If it's not your own original art, could you use your graphic designer skills to replace any non-original parts with original work? I think originality is one of the most important things that will influence my vote. Overall, it's a clean image but it needs something to make it stand out. Heddy (talk) 14:44, 8 May 2022 (UTC)
• Neutral. Building on this, I think it looks colourful enough to stand up well as Splatoon-related, but I agree with Heddy in that the squid could stand out more from the background and the wordmark could stand out more from the squid. But aside from that, I like it! GloverMist (talk) 15:06, 8 May 2022 (UTC)
• Neutral. I do like how it's nice and clean, but as mentioned above, it feels like it doesn't entirely stand out. For me, while I do like the attempt to add some more contrast, it still doesn't entirely pop to me. It has potential to be great, but it doesn't feel attention-grabbing. Maybe, as mentioned prior, make the squid stand out a bit more? Keep on trying, it's got potential! ShadowLugia250 (talk) 16:28, 8 May 2022 (UTC)

Neutral. I like the simplicity of it yet it looks a bit busy with the ink drops when the icon is small. The wordmark also looks cramped in small size which makes it a bit harder to read. Shahar (talk) 17:42, 8 May 2022 (UTC)

• Neutral. I think this has potential! Since you can't draw by yourself, I'd advise looking for better ink splats, specially from the second or 3rd game (there are tons of different graphics from nintendo!), and avoid using transparency for them, and also work on a better font for the wordmark ninckmane (talk) 17:45, 8 May 2022 (UTC)
• Neutral. I think this is really cool, and it's a great starting point! I feel like the colors of the squid and ink together don't contrast enough, and the semi transparency bothers me a bit. I think with a few minor adjustments, this could look even better! WoomyGirl85 (talk) 12:37, 9 May 2022 (UTC)

Proposal 3

ninckmane (talk) 14:08, 8 May 2022 (UTC)
I think its worth pointing out that the logo kinda looks like a compass... wasn't intentional but I think its a fun detail considering its a wiki site lol

Name	Icon		Wordmark		Logo		Notes
1							Tried to go for a more simple, dynamic style, its also very easy to change the logo colors! The typography I made is based on SquidSquad's Logo, but adapted for better readability
2							Tried to follow the ink droplets motif to make the Squid and Octo's face, though it comes at the cost of a little personality...

Comments

• Support. This isn't what I was expecting to see, in the best kind of way. Very clean, very stylish, simple in a way that pops! I appreciate the addition of an octo and like how it could be customisable too, though I definitely prefer the first version with the outlines around the eyes to make them look a bit more alive. My only thought is about the P the wordmark looking a bit like a lowercase R, but this is still very cool! GloverMist (talk) 15:06, 8 May 2022 (UTC)
• Support. A very refreshing unique simple and effective idea! The squid and octopus contrast makes for a fun representation of Inklings and Octolings, but as mentioned by GloverMist, the version with the outlines adds more life. It's really cool! ShadowLugia250 (talk) 16:34, 8 May 2022 (UTC)
• Support. I like this one. A modern look would definitely be a good logo to choose. The first one is the more preferable of the two, I think the second one does lack identity (to which you could fix in later version), but overall this one speaks to me. -- PanchamBro (talk • contributions) 17:00, 8 May 2022 (UTC)
• Support. I like it a lot, reminds me of Yin and yang. I think the eyes are a bit low and the octo looks a bit more of a jellyfish than a monster of tentacles. I like the simplicity of it, makes it clean, clear and abstract which is very common lately. The wordmark I presume suppose to resemble language inscriptions seen in the game world. It may need to be adjusted to be easier to read, letters like D and O, P and R, E looks a bit too bold that in smaller sizes it resembles the filled-in D. Overall I think it's very beautiful. Shahar (talk) 17:42, 8 May 2022 (UTC)
• Support. I really, really like where this is going. I actually like the second more than the first; maybe you will find a compromise or better solution if you feel it has lost personality. One complaint I have is the colors. I feel that these colors only represent Splatoon 3, but this wiki is about the entire Splatoon series and I feel the logo should reflect that or at least not be so obviously themed after one game. Plus I just don't like those colors in general, they sort of have a "nauseated" feel to them, lol 🤢🤮. Again, I really like this and hope I'm not the only one who doesn't like the colors. Heddy (talk) 21:45, 8 May 2022 (UTC)
• Support. Very simple and elegant. I really like the font on the wordmark. User:Eminence/Sig3 10:26, 9 May 2022 (UTC)
• Support. I love the simplicity and the font, and it seems like it really fits in with Inkipedia and Splatoon as a whole! I wouldn't mind seeing it with different color set, but I love how unique it is while really going along with all the in-game logos and such. Great job! WoomyGirl85 (talk) 12:37, 9 May 2022 (UTC)

Proposal 4

!WORDMARK COMING SOON! Constructive Feedback please. oneeye (talk) 19:16, 9 May 2022 (UTC)

Name	Icon		Notes
1	File:Inkipedia Logo Contest 2022 - Oneeye - Icon Proposal 1.png	File:Inkipedia Logo Contest 2022 - Oneeye - Icon Proposal 1.png
2	File:Inkipedia Logo Contest 2022 - Oneeye - Icon Proposal 2.png	File:Inkipedia Logo Contest 2022 - Oneeye - Icon Proposal 2.png	This one is more pixel art like and has less shading. ps: I (kind of) know how to use vector graphics :)
3	File:Inkipedia Logo Contest 2022 - Oneeye - Icon Proposal 3.svg	File:Inkipedia Logo Contest 2022 - Oneeye - Icon Proposal 3.svg	I tried my best making a vector graphic using scratch. Something went wrong uploading it I guess...

Comments

• Neutral. I like this idea! I think it's creative and represents the game well. But you are missing half of the assets asked for in the submission guidelines. Regarding the drawing, I think making it simpler is the way to go, considering that the idea is to have it vectorized for use on the site. You have a good idea, but it still needs the wordmark to tie it all together! There are a lot of ways to go for making it, maybe basing it off a script in the game, or using a font that you think represents the logo. ninckmane (talk) 21:05, 9 May 2022 (UTC)
• I do agree that it may benefit from less shading and more simplicity, as icons need to be simple to look good at small sizes. As I said when you posted on Discord, I love it. Looking forward to your progress on the wordmark and logo as well! Heddy (talk) 22:03, 9 May 2022 (UTC)
• Now that I see the first and second jelly icon, I think the second one looks cuter! Though I am unsure about going full pixel art, it could work. Just my opinion. It might help you decide what to do if you go ahead and draft wordmark and logo and collect feedback on those as well. (Also - Don't worry about vector graphics, just do what you think will make the most amazing logo!) Heddy (talk) 09:21, 10 May 2022 (UTC)
  • Scratch that, I think the second one looks better at the smaller size, but the first one looks better at the bigger size. Heddy (talk) 09:32, 10 May 2022 (UTC)
• I think it's beautiful. The Question mark in the back looks like the Jellyfish is holding a seaweed. I like the pixel art, I'd love to see more variants along with the wordmark and logo. Shahar (talk) 10:29, 10 May 2022 (UTC)

Proposal 5

Honestly, I made this because I like the Splatoon series and was bored. I'm just a beginner graphic designer. K Kit (talk) 23:53, 9 May 2022 (UTC)

Name	Icon		Wordmark		Logo		Notes
1							Splatoon always seemed like a relatively music themed game to me. I guess thats the theme of this. I don't expect to win, but I think this looks pretty good, with the theme colors of every game.(Accidentally s3 is the somewhat main colors, I realized this after I made the color palette for it.)I'm always looking for feedback!

Comments

• Weak support. For the wordmark, there appears to be some empty space on the borders; it would be best to crop that out so that the wordmark doesn't have any padding (trust me, there is plenty of padding added whenever wikis use the wordmark, so the wordmark itself should generally not have padding). The squid seems to clash with the rest of the art style; could you tweak that somehow, maybe draw the squid in your own style if you can? I wonder, could this somehow be made more dance-y? I'm imagining a squid dancing and shaking maracas with tentacles, lol, not sure how that would work in a logo so just ignore me I guess. Your logo has potential! Have fun with it, and you could do something amazing! Heddy (talk) 06:10, 10 May 2022 (UTC)
• Weak support. I think it's very cool. The speakers with the music nodes make it look like a groovy logo. I think it would be more fitting if our site was solely a media service. Shahar (talk) 10:29, 10 May 2022 (UTC)
• Weak support. I like it, however I do agree with what Heddy said. User:Eminence/Sig3 10:48, 10 May 2022 (UTC)

Proposal 6

I had fun working on it. I wanted to make the logo look like a squid that is hiding in ink on the wall with brush movements of ink in the background. Don't crucify me please only positive and constructive comments. Shahar (talk) 09:51, 10 May 2022 (UTC)

Name	Icon		Wordmark		Logo		Notes
1							Font is Ethnocentric which can be used for logos and web graphics.

Comments

• Weak Support. I like the logo, my only concern with the wordmark is that the colors look very similar to the already existing wordmark. I would prefer if the border on the wordmark wasn't as rounded and the color was changed, maybe yellow? Other than that, good logo! User:Eminence/Sig3 10:45, 10 May 2022 (UTC)

Proposal 7

This is my first time uploading anything here so I'm sorry if I screw up. Anyways, I decided to add graffiti and stickers from all 3 games and the Octo Expansion, the wordmark is in the font "Inkling" that was made by u/frozenpandaman on Reddit (the font can only be used with credit so if that doesn't work for a logo, I can change it to a regular font that isn't Splatoon-specific). — Preceding unsigned comment added by MK Squid (talk • contribs) 10:17, 10 May 2022 (UTC)

Name	Icon		Wordmark		Logo		Notes
1

Comments

Support. This looks really cool! The only thing that may need a change to me is the font may seem a little hard to read to people new to the Splatoon and the wiki. This looks really good, and I hope you get far in the contest. K Kit (talk) 15:44, 10 May 2022 (UTC)

Proposal 8

Optionally replace this text with anything you want to say about your proposal

Use 4 tildes (~~~~) to add your signature

Replace this text with a table displaying the submission

Proposal 9

Optionally replace this text with anything you want to say about your proposal

Use 4 tildes (~~~~) to add your signature

Replace this text with a table displaying the submission